Lost Dutchman Rare Coins

Lost Dutchman Rare Coins logo

Lost Dutchman Rare Coins

Opening hours

4983 North Franklin Road
Indianapolis, IN 46226

Services

Book

Collection Appraisal

. Duration:1 hr·
Book

Written Insurance Apprasial

. Duration:1 hr·
Book

Scrap Gold Sales

. Duration:15 mins·
Book

Watches

. Duration:15 mins·
Book

Sell Us Bullion

. Duration:15 mins·
Book

Wholesale Tranactions

. Duration:1 hr·
Book

Sell Coins 1-10 Coins

. Duration:15 mins·
Book

Sell Coins 11-50 Coins

. Duration:20 mins·
Book

Sell Coins 50-250 Coins

. Duration:30 mins·
Book

Sell Coins 250+ Coins

. Duration:1 hr·
Book

Military Collectibles

. Duration:30 mins·

About

Lost Dutchman Rare Coins has been the premier full service coin shop in Indianapolis since 1983. We specialize in buying and selling collectible coins, paper money, and bullion. As a family run local business we value our customers. Your satisfaction is our number one priority whether it’s selling to us or adding to your collection. We offer the following services.

FREE in office appraisals.
Numismatic Consulting.
PCGS, PMG, NGC, & CAC submission center.
Gold, Silver, Platinum, Palladium buyers and sellers.
Top Prices Paid For Broken and Unused Gold & Silver Jewelry

Good to know
Social media

Reviews

, Highest rated
73
1
0
0
0
74 reviews
  • Roger Butler
    ·

    Great experience. I went to get a rough idea of valuation of my late father-in-law's collection for estate purposes. Bruce gave me no nonsense values and good advice. But I was even more impressed with how Bruce treated a young customer who was in before me. The guy was probably around 10 and was obviously just getting started in coin collecting. He picked out a couple of what must have been starter coins, then a $50 silver coin. Bruce offered him a free copy of a collector's guide, but he said he already had it. When his mom paid, Bruce took $50 for the silver coin, but gave him the starter coins free along with a bag full of what must have been interesting but face value coins. What a great thing to do. Bruce is obviously both a consummate professional and eager to encourage the next generation of coin collectors. I would go out of my way to give him my business.

  • Garry Houghton
    ·

    I booked an appointment to sell some silver bullion. I was given a fair price based on the current spot value of silver, the process was painless. Thanks Spencer.

  • Curtis Linke
    ·

    Lost Dutchmen is THE place to go for appraisals and sale of coins. Knowledgeable and fast, but most importantly honest. I took in a collection where I had sorted the gold from the "other" coins. Gold was just to be appraised, other coins sold. While going through other coins, Lost Dutchman found some gold coins with several thousand. Could have kept quiet, but they did not, giving me the gold back.