Lost Dutchman Rare Coins

Lost Dutchman Rare Coins logo

Lost Dutchman Rare Coins

Opening hours

4983 North Franklin Road
Indianapolis, IN 46226

Services

Book

Scrap Gold Sales

. Duration:15 mins
Book

Watches

. Duration:15 mins
Book

Sell Us Bullion

. Duration:15 mins
Book

Wholesale Tranactions

. Duration:1 hr
Book

Sell Coins 1-10 Coins

. Duration:15 mins
Book

Sell Coins 11-50 Coins

. Duration:20 mins
Book

Sell Coins 50-250 Coins

. Duration:30 mins
Book

Sell Coins 250+ Coins

. Duration:1 hr
Book

Military Collectibles

. Duration:30 mins

About

Lost Dutchman Rare Coins has been the premier full service coin shop in Indianapolis since 1983. We specialize in buying and selling collectible coins, paper money, and bullion. As a family run local business we value our customers. Your satisfaction is our number one priority whether it’s selling to us or adding to your collection. We offer the following services.

FREE in office appraisals.
Numismatic Consulting.
PCGS, PMG, NGC, & CAC submission center.
Gold, Silver, Platinum, Palladium buyers and sellers.
Top Prices Paid For Broken and Unused Gold & Silver Jewelry

Reviews

, Highest rated
78
1
0
0
0
79 reviews
  • John Tzucker
    ·

    I went to Lost Dutchman with questions, need for evaluations and several coins I was interested in selling. My questions revolved around grading, cleaning and minor mint errors. My questions were answered in a way that furthered my knowledge of collecting and they even bought one of the coins I had asked about. They helped me in learning about how to recognize coins that had been cleaned and how to evaluate coins with damage. I found their offers to buy quite reasonable and left with better understanding of the coins they did not purchase. All in all a great visit and I look forward to doing future business there.

  • Mike Dearing
    ·

    I returned from Michigan to have the Lost Dutchman staff appraise my coin collection and other items. As always in the past, they were professional and very easy to deal with. I was very pleased with the outcome as I sold all of my collection with a nice profit. I highly recommend the Lost Dutchman for your needs. Thank you gentlemen.

  • Allison Hunt
    ·

    Super nice and approachable service. Gave a fair deal for some silver I inherited and were gracious enough to appraise some old coins even though I wasn’t interested in selling them. Highly recommend! Also some really cool stuff to look at while you wait.