Lost Dutchman Rare Coins logo

Lost Dutchman Rare Coins

Opening hours

4983 North Franklin Road, Indianapolis, Indiana,in

Services

Book

Collection Appraisal

. Duration:1 hr·
Book

Written Insurance Apprasial

. Duration:1 hr·
Book

Scrap Gold Sales

. Duration:15 mins·
Book

Watches

. Duration:15 mins·
Book

Sell Us Bullion

. Duration:15 mins·
Book

Wholesale Tranactions

. Duration:1 hr·
Book

Sell Coins 1-10 Coins

. Duration:15 mins·

About us

Lost Dutchman Rare Coins has been the premier full service coin shop in Indianapolis since 1983. We specialize in buying and selling collectible coins, paper money, and bullion. As a family run local business we value our customers. Your satisfaction is our number one priority whether it’s selling to us or adding to your collection. We offer the following services.

FREE in office appraisals.
Numismatic Consulting.
PCGS, PMG, NGC, & CAC submission center.
Gold, Silver, Platinum, Palladium buyers and sellers.
Top Prices Paid For Broken and Unused Gold & Silver Jewelry

Opening hours

Cancellation policy

Reviews

58 reviews
  • MHW·

    Great job! Thank you!

  • frederick lalley·

    Being a complete novice in this area I was very happy with the navigation of the process by Spencer. I would certainly recommend Lost Dutchman to anyone needing guidance with the coin valuation process.

  • Tim K·

    I wouldn't hesitate to recommend this company to my grandmother. They exceeded my minimum acceptable amount by nearly 30%. I've always been treated well as a buyer but this time, as a seller it was even better. Dot sell to anyone until you've given this company a chance to make you an offer.

  • Sara·

    This was my first time visiting this store for a collections appraisal of old coins I found. Bruce was very kind, informative and was able to give me some information on a unique coin I'd had for years. Highly recommend this business if you're new to coins or an avid collector.

  • Ted B.·

    Great doing business with! Would do so again in a heartbeat!

  • Jeff·

    I dealt with Spencer. This was my second visit. Very easy transaction . Straightforward no hassle pricing. Very nice experience. I will be back in the future at some point.

Show all reviews

Address